Walk on Earth a Stranger by Rae Carson


Lee Westfall has a strong, loving family. She has a home she loves and a loyal steed. She has a best friend—who might want to be something more.

She also has a secret.

Lee can sense gold in the world around her. Veins deep in the earth. Small nuggets in a stream. Even gold dust caught underneath a fingernail. She has kept her family safe and able to buy provisions, even through the harshest winters. But what would someone do to control a girl with that kind of power? A person might murder for it.

When everything Lee holds dear is ripped away, she flees west to California—where gold has just been discovered. Perhaps this will be the one place a magical girl can be herself. If she survives the journey.

The acclaimed Rae Carson begins a sweeping new trilogy set in Gold Rush-era America, about a young woman with a powerful and dangerous gift.

Before reading this book, I was largely ignorant to the California Gold Rush between 1848 to 1855. After reading Walk on Earth a Stranger, I may still be far from fluent in the history but Carson has written a wonderful story that gives us insight to what it might have been like, propelled by one heck of a sweeping story about what it means to be brave.

The story follows Leah Westfall, a girl who possesses the incredible gift of being able to sense gold. In such difficult times, such a gift can be a blessing but can also mean immense danger for Leah. Paired with the growing fever for gold, Leah’s powers and their significance in the story’s time period creates a fascinating narrative tinged with magical realism. Although her powers play a minute but important part in her journey, Walk on Earth a Stranger is more about Leah, her adventure, and the unexpected friends that she makes along the way.

When there’s gold to be had, you can’t trust anyone. Not a single soul.

Walk on Earth a Stranger may be historical fiction, but at its heart, it is an adventure – and it was a splendid one, at that. Not only was there stunning character development with Leah emerging changed after her journey, but the trek to California presented many dangers and complications. Carson’s exploration of these obstacles – from bandits to harsh terrain – gave its setting life and dimension. The pace may be slow, but Carson takes the time to flesh out every detail and tinder the senses. The story also briefly examines sexism and racism, underpinning small but significant details that were, unfortunately, faithful to its time period.

In a sense, Walk on Earth a Stranger is a very character-driven book. It took a long time to get invested into the writing, but once I was, I was hooked. Once I made that emotional connection with Leah and grew to care for her. I shared Leah’s fears, her joys, her pains, and her triumphs. By seizing control of her destiny and disguising herself as a man, Leah embarks on a journey that is not only a physical one, but one that is deeply personal and emotional. Leah’s growth as a brave and compassionate person is absolutely wonderful and fulfilling to behold.

It turns out that a girl with all the friends in the world is still lonely when she’s keeping secrets.

Underneath the book’s spirited adventure, what ultimately stole my heart was its fantastic characters and their unfaltering strength and determination. That when they finally reached the end of their journey, it may have come with so many sacrifices and loss, but it was a victory that was hard-won and deserved. The bonds made and strengthened felt all the more precious and stronger through their shared pain and tribulation. More so, Walk on Earth a Stranger shows that strength is not just being able to survive or being stoic; the story shows that real strength can be perseverance and compassion when the two are extremely difficult.

In a sea of complex stories, Walk on Earth a Stranger is a nugget of a book. Its story may be simple, but it possesses a rare sincerity that is helplessly likable and endearing. Even if you aren’t terribly fond of Westerns or interested in history (and I fall into both categories) Walk on Earth a Stranger is sure to be an unexpected and humble book; one about taking control of your destiny, venturing into great unknown, and finding family in the most of unlikely of places and people.

Rating: 3.5/5

Book Information
Book Name: Walk on Earth a Stranger
Book Series: The Gold Seer Trilogy
Author: Rae Carson
Publisher: Greenwillow Books
Format: Audiobook

Walk on Earth a Stranger in:
Goodreads | Book Depository | My review on Goodreads

UPDATE 23/10: It was recently brought to my attention that Walk on Earth a Stranger has problematic representation of Native American people and history. Please read this extensive analysis of the chapters (contains spoilers), as well as this Tumblr post which details the book’s problematic elements. Thank you to Daisy and Glaiza for sharing these two links with me.


I listened to the audiobook and the narrator was amazing. I loved her narration to bits; she captured the accent and feel of the book so, so well.

  • Have you read Walk on Earth a Stranger? Did you like it?
  • For those who are familiar with its historical context, is it accurate? (Aside from a quick read of the Wikipedia page, I know barely anything!)
  • Have you read the book’s sequel, Like a River Glorious?

15 thoughts on “Walk on Earth a Stranger by Rae Carson

  1. What a lovely review, as always <3 I'm not into historical books too much, actually, but you made me curious about that one, mainly because of how you insist on the characters' journey, and if you know me a little bit, well, characters are the best ahah. I'm curious about that gift that the main character has, as well, and how it translates into the story and how she lives with it. I think I'll have to think about adding this book to my TBR :)

    • Hi Marie!

      Oh gosh, thank you. <3 The character development in this book is wonderful, and probably my favourite part of the book! The only thing is that I just edited my review and added a few links at the end. The links go to analyses of the book, where someone critiqued the representation of Native American peoples and history in Walk on Earth a Stranger. I had no idea it was problematic and I was so disappointed that it was, but it's well worth the read!

  2. Awesome review CW! I had the same thoughts as you when I read it, in that I loved the plot and I LOVED reading about the Oregon trail and the west (because I played so much of Oregon Trail the game when I was younger). I have yet to read Like A River Glorious, but my friend has and absolutely loved it!

    • Hi Val!
      I’m glad you enjoyed it! :D I’ve never heard of that game?! But I love those kinds of games – the ones that educate us about history. <3
      I'm a little conflicted about my feelings about it, but I'm just raising awareness of the criticisms of this book. My two friends shared it with me, so I feel like I should share it with you too.
      At the bottom of my review, I've shared two posts that explain why this book had very problematic rep of Native American peoples and history. It's well-worth the read, and has made me reevaluate the book!

  3. I have been waiting with baited breath for this series to finish– I’m the sort of person who wants to binge read series. 😳 I love how you highlight the character development. That’s essential to my enjoyment for a book. And historical fiction set during the Gold Rush with a strong female protagonist? Yes please!

    • Hi Jackie!
      Haha, I’m the complete opposite! I’m terrible at sticking to series. I’ve read so many first books but haven’t read any second, third, etc ones. 😅

      The character development is great! Definitely one of my favourite parts of the novel. I have to warn you about the book though – I only just found out, so I only updated it, but at the bottom of my review I included some links that analyze the problematic parts of the book (i.e. very problematic rep of Native American peoples). I think it is well worth reading – then it’s up to you whether you want to read it or not!

      • Ugh. Thanks for the update! For some reason, I’m forgiving of poor portrayals of diverse characters if the books are pre-1955, but I struggle with modern books doing this. It’s like a give older authors a pass; “Oh they didn’t know any better.” But I shouldn’t. Particularly if this turns me off a bit about Rae’s newest novel.
        <— Hypocrite. Oops.
        (I'll probably still read this.)

    • Hi Alexa!
      It’s SORT of fantasy, but I’d categorize it as historical fiction first and fantasy second! In saying this though, I added two links at the bottom of my review today because the book was problematic in its rep of Native American peoples and history, so definitely give that a read first!

    • Hi Glaiza!
      Thank you for sharing that link with me! Daisy sent me the very same link, so I am definitely going to add that link at the bottom of my review somewhere. Thank you very much for highlighting this though. <3

      Fair enough! Now that I'm aware of the problematic elements of her book, I am hesitant to continue. I do like her writing though, so perhaps I'll give her other books a try too.

      • I always wanted to read her debut fantasy book because the heroine wasn’t a typically thin heroine and tackled some body perception issues, which I’ve gleaned from friend’s recommendations of it. I’m definitely open to reading her books and I wouldn’t discourage anyone from reading this particular series as long as they have an awareness of the problematic elements. I have a different book on my physical TBR, which I didn’t realise was problematic but if I do end up reviewing it, I’ll probably add a link as well.

Leave a Reply! I'd love to hear your thoughts/comments. <3

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s